The national popular vote movement to replace the electoral college now, over two centuries after the electoral college went into effect, there is a highly funded movement, the national popular vote movement npv, to replace this key component of our constitutional republic. Under the national popular vote interstate compact, every vote would have equal value, but neither party would have an automatic advantage. A statebased plan for electing the president by national popular vote. This effort is known as the national popular vote npv compact. The national popular vote plan does not do away with the electoral college system, an action that would require a constitutional amendment. The national popular vote, explained brennan center for justice.
The npv is a multistate agreement that, when active, would ensure that the presidential candidate who wins the popular vote nationally also wins in the electoral college. In defense of the electoral college national affairs. The bill would reform the electoral college so that the electoral vote in the electoral college reflects the choice of the nations voters for president of the united states. Why does tom emmer support national popular vote, and who is behind it. National popular vote election, part 2 the hill newspaper and the making every vote count foundation hosted an event at the newseum in washington, d. Pass the national popular vote compact and reform the outdated, antidemocratic electoral college. Page 276 whereas, a large number of state legislatures have at various times adopted memorials and resolutions in favor of the election of united states senators by popular vote. This book explains the dangerous and unconstitutional implications of the national popular vote bill, which is quietly passing in state houses across the nation.
Why we should abolish the electoral college the new york times. National popular vote national conference of state. The national popular vote plan to bypass the electoral college. Would a national popular vote remove some politics from. Tom golisano american businessman and philanthropist tom golisano is the founder and chairman of paychex, the nations second largest payroll and human resource company. The most commonly used systems are the plurality system and the tworound system for singlewinner. The agreement among the states to elect the president by national popular vote.
The npv compact despite minor differences in the various npv bills, there are a few aspects common to all of them. Aug 17, 2016 rodney dodsworth august 17, 2016 september 22, 2018 comments off on the national popular vote. The npv is a multistate agreement that, when active, would ensure that the presidential candidate who wins the popular vote nationally also wins in the electoral. Challenge of national popular vote makes colorados 2020. A national popular vote for president would make a vote cast in hawaii as important as a vote in new hampshire and ohio by dr.
However, the popular vote is not used to determine who is elected as the nations president or vice president. Jan 05, 2011 every vote equal is a book that argues that this system should be abolished in favor of a national popular vote. In a presidential election, the popular vote simply means an aggregate of all voters from all states in america. National association for the advancement of colored people naacp at its 2008 annual convention in cincinnati, ohio, the naacp adopted a resolution pdf, 54kb in support of the proposition of a national popular vote for president in general and the national popular vote plan in particular.
Jun 10, 2019 the alternative, a truly national election based on the popular vote tally, would yield a president with national legitimacyto be surebut a kind of legitimacy that could come at the expense of federal legitimacy. The radical alternative is the national popular vote interstate compactcall it the compact, for short. The danger of the national popular vote compact harvard. Mar 03, 2014 why does tom emmer support national popular vote, and who is behind it. President once the national popular vote has enough states in agreement for 270 electors, we will all be able to vote for the president as americans. A repeal of colorados new national popular vote law. In the course of writing a book on the history of the electoral college and the case for a national popular vote, i spoke to dozens of campaign managers, field. A statebased plan for electing the president by national popular vote and originator of the national popular vote legislation. Why national popular vote would be a disaster for america.
National popular vote to appear on the ballot this fall. Pdf should the country replace the electoral collegebased presidential election system with a direct popular election of a president. A national popular vote for president isnt as close as. Jul 25, 20 national popular vote is a campaign launched in the mid2000s. The method by which the winner or winners of a direct election are chosen depends upon the electoral system used. Why democrats hate the electoral college and republicans. The national popular vote effort, explained washington post. When a state passes legislation to join the national popular vote compact, it pledges that all of that states electoral. National popular vote supporters launch campaign to keep.
A well documented argument in favor of electing the president by a national popular vote. History is littered with shortlive democracies that cratered between the bloodlettings of factions going at each others throats. The npvc is a proposed interstate compact in which the signatory states agree that they will appoint their presidential electors in accordance with the national popular vote rather than their own state electorates vote. A direct, national popular vote would incentivize campaigns to focus almost exclusively on densely populated urban areas. Thats how were taught democracy works, and its how it works in most countries, but it isnt. The electoral college, national popular vote, and the. If we reran the 2016 election, hillary would have won, but of course. But the winner of the popular vote may end up losing the election, like al gore did in 2000 and hillary clinton in 2016. Let the people pick the president addresses electoral. May 25, 2018 popular vote plan would do more harm than good. The national popular vote effort is now halfway to its goal of electing future presidents via the popular vote, after rhode island gov. America would finally elect a president of the united states and not a president of the battleground states of america. Last month, the new york times joined the chorus for the national popular vote npvthe idea that we should scrap the electoral college and elect our presidents with a single nationwide popular vote.
Koza april 16, 2007 the national popular vote bill, which was recently signed into law in maryland and which recently passed the hawaii house and senate, would guarantee the presidency to the candidate who. Direct election is a system of choosing political officeholders in which the voters directly cast ballots for the persons, or political party that they desire to see elected. The group developed and champions the adoption of the national popular vote interstate compact, which is an agreement among a group of u. April 3, 2019 new mexico governor grisham signed the national popular vote bill, thereby making new mexico the 15th jurisdiction to enact the bill. The national popular vote npv movement emerged in late 2006 and has slowly gain some steam since then. The bill would reform the electoral college so that the electoral vote in the electoral college reflects the choice of the nations voters for.
Oct 07, 2019 national popular vote election, part 1 the hill newspaper and the making every vote count foundation hosted an event at the newseum in washington, d. Learn more about national popular vote from chapter 9 of our book every vote equal. In 2019, colorado, new mexico, delaware and oregon became the latest states to take a stand against the electoral college and join the national popular vote interstate compact npv. Lincoln chafee d made his state the latest to sign on. On april 14, the yes on national popular vote committee launched a campaign to get coloradans to approve the law. In the course of writing a book on the history of the electoral college and the case for a national popular vote, i spoke to dozens of campaign managers, field directors, groundgame coordinators. The compact is designed to ensure that the candidate who receives the. Every vote equal is a book that argues that this system should be abolished in favor of a national popular vote.
With answers to 1 myths about the national popular vote plan fourth editionfebruary 20 by john r. A statebased plan for electing the president by national popular vote a 620page book describing its proposal. Apr 27, 2020 but in a close national popular vote election, where the victorious candidate has, say, 20 percent of the vote and the runnerup has 19 percent, there would be powerful incentives to litigate allegations of fraud in virtually every state, leaving the country without a duly elected president until that litigation is ultimately settled at the. Clintons popular vote edge in 2016 arose from democratic voting in just two places. It won final approval of the naacp board on october. Instead, it modifies the winnertakeall rule in a way its supporters say would assure that every vote will matter in every state in every presidential election.
Floridians for national popular vote making sure every. Robert richie coauthors the fourth edition of every vote equal, a book explaining and supporting the national popular vote interstate compact 2014. In 2006, john koza, a computer science professor at stanford, was the lead author of every vote equal, a book that makes a detailed case for his plan for an. National popular vote to appear on the ballot this fall the wire. From 1973 through 1987, he was cofounder, chairman, and ceo of scientific games inc. If it doesnt pass, then that just means that its off the books in colorado. Seven reasons to elect the president by popular vote.
Electoral vote vs popular vote difference and comparison. Likewise, fairvote president rob richie coauthored the book every vote equal, which explains and defends the proposal. In a wide enough field, a special interest candidate could easily win with less than a quarter of the national popular vote, and for this reason there will. Dont believe the myths about a national popular vote. But a new poll in those great lakes states indicates a significant majority of those voters would prefer to have presidents elected by the national popular vote instead of decided through the. Interstate agreement to elect president of the united states by national popular vote. The national popular vote interstate compact npvic is an agreement among a group of u.
The national popular vote, explained brennan center for. This past week, colorado joined a growing list of states that have signed on to the national popular vote compact npvc. April 30, 2019 the minnesota house passed the national popular vote bill, making it the 38th state legislative chamber to have passed the bill. The national popular vote debate is also likely to find its way into colorados other 2020 elections, including the race for u. A statebased plan for electing the president by national popular votea 620page book describing its proposal. Mar, 2020 in the course of writing a book on the history of the electoral college and the case for a national popular vote, i spoke to dozens of campaign managers, field directors, groundgame coordinators. National popular vote bill clears house of delegates. February 23, 2006 national popular vote releases every vote equal. National popular vote legislation works within the framework of the constitution, preserving the electoral system and guaranteeing the presidency to.
In our countrys history, there have only been four times when the popular vote exceeded the electoratal vote. First, the electoral college forces candidates to appeal to a wider range of voters. Consider the recorded national popular vote margins in 1880 and 1960. National popular vote interstate compact wikipedia. Get a local group to make the method of electing the president the topic of a guest speaker, panel. Among the arguments that the book details is that it gives voters in different states unequal. The act makes law and enters into with all other states joining therein the agreement among the states to elect the president of the united states by national popular vote agreement. Mar 17, 2020 the last few chapters debunk popular myths about the electoral college and show how a national popular vote might work. Apr 21, 2017 wouldnt a simple national popular vote be better. Fairvote has a long history with respect to the national popular vote. The book describes, in detail, an interstate compact entitled the agreement among the states to elect the president by national popular vote. List of united states presidential elections by popular.
Koza is originator of the agreement among the states to elect the president by national popular vote described in this book. But again, if the national popular vote was determinative, every vote would matter. Email updates text of bill every vote equal book donate. National popular vote electoral college reform by direct. Americans reached a new high in support for having presidential elections based on the popular vote instead of the electoral college, according to a new poll from the public religion research. This book is an extremely detailed argument for why the electoral college is no longer an appropriate system for electing the president.
1511 685 1196 1432 464 22 839 137 1566 82 91 1535 908 1492 795 1434 1637 1445 1380 1618 1022 793 1583 185 492 970 1116 790 431 142 298 241 927 280 1109 148 940 71 269 312 520 80