No man knows my history

No man knows my history is the definitive tale of smiths life. In reconsidering no man knows my history newell bringhurst has compiled an impressive volume of original scholarship on brodie and her biography of joseph smith. Brodie is a history of joseph smith, prophet, seer, revelator and first president of the church of jesus christ of latterday saints from the point of view of an unbeliever, whose whole focus is to prove him to be a charlatan, a fake and a fraud. Fawn mckay brodie is no mormon herself, she does not believe in what joseph smith preached, and she does not dwell deeply on the spiritual development of latterday joseph smith was born to a poor farm family in vermont in 1805. The first paperback edition of the classic biography of the founder of the mormon church, this book attempts to.

Brodie was raised in an lds family, but the work is not a. No man knows is way worse than most outsiders and exmormons think it is, but i also think no man knows is better than many believers give brodie credit for. Full text of no man knows my history internet archive. Brodie 1971, hardcover, revised at the best online prices at ebay. Fawn mckay brodie in 1823 a young man named joseph smith had an encounter with an angel who led him to a cache of golden plates purporting to be the history. When i finished the book, i thought that if 10% of it was accurate, the mormon church certainly wasnt what it. She was known nationally for her historical works on thomas jefferson and richard nixon, but among the mormons was best known as author of no man knows my history, a biography of joseph smith, jr. The life of joseph smith is a 1945 book by fawn mckay brodie. No man knows my herstory is a podcast about mormonism hosted by cari and kelsae, two queer exmormon women. Perhaps it is time for nonmormon historians to examine once again fawn m. Fawn mckay brodie september 15, 1915 january 10, 1981 was an american biographer and one of the first female professors of histor y at ucla, who is best known for thomas jefferson.

The most interesting and most accessible article, i think, is the first, which is entitled a biography of the biography. Fawn mckay brodie this highly praised biography, revised and enlarged with new material, takes its title from a halfdefiant, halfwistful pronouncement joseph smith. Heres where you can request audio versions of no man knows. I never did harm any man since i was born in the world. No man knows my history the life of joseph smith the. Such a project is less a question of ideology than a fairly objective determination of whether the footnote citations of no man knows my history really support its thesis. I dont know how real the chances are, but i have issues with reading text on a page, so i listen to audible. Scourge of the south, and her bestseller, thomas jefferson. She was the author of five biographies, four of which incorporate freudian psychology, including no man knows my history.

Palmyra newspapers took no notice of josephs vision at the time it was supposed to have occurred. The life of joseph smith lesson plans include daily lessons, fun activities, essay topics, testquiz questions, and more. A n intimate histo ry 1974, a work of psychobiography, and no man knows my histo ry 1945, an early and still influential biography of joseph smith, the founder of the latter day saint movement. Brodie 1995, paperback, enlarged at the best online prices at ebay. An intimate history, a work of psychobiography, and no man knows my history, the first prominent nonhagiographic biography of joseph smith, jr. Brodie was raised in an lds family, but the work is not a hagiography. It is honest and realistic about the truth behind joseph smith. Response to claims made in no man knows my history.

Heres where you can request audio versions of no man knows my history and in sacred loneliness on amazon i noticed there is a button to report interest to audible. It is the first important nonhagiographic biography of joseph smith. First published in 1945 and substantially revised in 1970, no man knows my history is a model of the biographers art by a writer who would later become famous for her study of thomas jefferson. Fawn mckay brodie is no mormon herself, she does not believe in what joseph smith preached, and she does not dwell deeply on the spiritual development of latterday sa joseph smith was. Publication date 1971 topics mormonism collection opensource language english. Featured texts all books all texts latest this just in smithsonian libraries fedlink us genealogy lincoln collection. If i had not experienced what i have, i would not have believed it myself. Criticism of mormonismbooksno man knows my history. Using the transcribed 1945 text although the late mrs. Just finished reading no man knows my history by fawn. Fawn mckay brodie in 1823 a young man named joseph smith had an encounter with an angel who led him to a cache of golden plates purporting to be the history of the lost tribes of israel. The book has not gone out of print, and 60 years after its first publication, its publisher, alfred a. Having just read bringhursts biography of brodie, a lot of this was redundant information for me. It is the first important non hagiographic biography of joseph smith, the founder of latter day saint movement.

The nook book ebook of the no man knows my history. Brodies nmkmy text is ed, it has been frequently quoted in large blocks, both in printed books and in online web pages. This was one of the first books i read in my search for truth. Full text of no man knows my history see other formats. Brodie was raised in an lds family, but the work is. Download pdf no man knows my history book full free. Joseph smith rap aint no man know my history youtube. The life of joseph smith, the mormon prophet in 1945, calling into serious question most of the faith claims based on mormonisms early history, an enormous amount of energy has been expended by mormon historians, apologists, and critics of all backgrounds and. Unflinchingly, brodie wrote of how the devout mormon must believe that the black. Reconsidering no man knows my history newell bringhurst on. Fawn brodie no man knows my history this is perhaps the most famous joseph smith biography. Brodie and a great selection of related books, art and collectibles available now at. Brodies book was groundbreaking for the time because almost all histories of smith before that time were pure polemics, either faithful hagiography or critical hate mongering. Fawn mckay brodie september 15, 1915 january 10, 1981 was a biographer and professor of history at ucla, best known for thomas jefferson.

Heres where you can request audio versions of no man. It is at once scholarly, riveting, and provocative in the questions it raises about smiths revelations, and, in doing so, provides a remarkable. Has anybody read no maam, thats not history by hugh nibley. Though fawn mckay brodie forged a reputation as a controversial psychohistorian, it is her 1945 biography of joseph smith for which she has always been known among latterday saints. Just finished reading no man knows my history by fawn brodie. His response to brodie took the form of counterpunching which signaled to the saints that there was still room for nonnaturalistic accounts of joseph smiths revelations. No man knows my history the life of joseph smith hbdj 1st1st at the best online prices at. The books style is somewhat oldfashioned it originally was published in 1945, and as history it is more scholarly than popular.

No man knows my history fawn brodie summary of book a biography about joseph smith. Brodies stillrespected earlier work, no man knows my history. Search the history of over 424 billion web pages on the internet. Brodie this study guide consists of approximately 105 pages of chapter summaries, quotes, character analysis, themes, and more everything you need to sharpen your knowledge of no man knows my history. Cohen anyone like me approaching the study of mormon history wet behind the ears soon confronts fawn mckay brodies famous or, in certain lds circles, infamous biography of joseph smith. Fawn mckay brodie this highly praised biography, revised and enlarged with new material, takes its title from a halfdefiant, halfwistful pronouncement joseph smith himself made toward the close of the short, tragic. No man knows my history quells my curiosity regarding joseph smith. Read the classic biography of the founder of the mormon church. Because this doublechecking may be done on a broader scale, stewarts work is a valuable pilot study of the validity of brodies generalizations. Best price no man knows my history 2 edition by fawn m. I couldnt put the thing downeven skipped part of church to read it.

Brodie presents the history of a man who has been an enigma, perhaps only because his past history has never fully been disclosed by the church of jesus christ of latter day saints, the mormons. Pdf no man knows my history download full pdf book. The life of joseph smith, the mormon prophetin november 1945. Reconsidering no man knows my history is essential reading for any student or scholar with an interest in mormon history, western americana, and literary biographical scholarship. It also serves as a history of the early mormon church and a window on the united states circa 1820 to 1845. Brodie notes that for the new england and new york ancestors of smith there was a contempt for the established church which had permeated the revolution, which had made the federal government completely secular, and which was in the end to divorce the church from. Fawn brodie, joseph smith, and psychoanalysis author charles l. Everything you need to teach no man knows my history. Fawn mckay brodie is no mormon herself, she does not believe in what joseph smith preached, and she does not dwell deeply on the spiritual development of latterday sa joseph smith was born to a poor farm family in vermont in 1805. Oct 18, 20 from the joseph smith papers joseph smiths first vision part 1 importance season 2 episode 16 full episode can be viewed at byutv. Brodie, in terms of her background and intelligence, seemed highly qualified to write a biography of mormonisms founder born fawn mckay in ogden, utah, on september 15, 1915, she was the daughter of thomas e.

A biography of the founder of mormonism joseph smith jr. The book no man knows my history by fawn mckay brodie, was a more recent updated version, which i did not expect. No man knows my history is well written and well documented. Brodies no man knows my history back of 1945 brodie book dust jacket. She thought of herself, and has been portrayed by cultural mormons, as an objective historian. The first paperback edition of the classic biography of the founder of the mormon church, this book attempts to answer the questions that continue to surround. Where to buy no man knows my history 2 edition by fawn m brodie paperback buy no man knows my history 2 edition by fawn m brodie paperback that is sturdy. No matter what your reason, this article will give you some great tips for selecting and purchasing new no man knows my history 2 edition by fawn m brodie paperback. I purchased the book as a used, in good condition copy. The life of joseph smith, by fawn mckay brodie, was the first important nonhagiographic biography of joseph smith, the founder of latt. No maam, thats not history by hugh nibley my comments are in italics preface. No maam, thats not history hugh nibley collection hbll. I refer to no man knows my history as the second best biograph of joseph smith.

It is a scholarly work but readable by the average educated adult. From the joseph smith papers joseph smiths first vision part 1 importance season 2 episode 16 full episode can be viewed at byutv. The first is the recently published, awardwinning book joseph smith. And it is withering in debunking the lds creation myths about the origins of the black race and the american indian race, as they are laid out in the books of mormon and abraham. The most powerful mormons in the world, as of today, march 4th, 2015. The first paperback edition of the classic biography of th. Brodie, in terms of her background and intelligence, seemed highly qualified to write a biography of mormonisms founder. Josephs mother reported that he was spinning theories about the mound builders before he was twenty years old authors sources.

She thought of herself, and has been portrayed by cultural mormons, as an. If there had been no fawn brodie, mormon historians would have had to invent her. No man knows my history available for download and read online in other formats. Listen now if we have the truth, it cannot be harmed by investigation. Former owners name and date penned on front pastedown. The authors of no man knows my history makes the following claim. Vogels book covers only the period from joseph smiths birth to late 1830 when smith moves from palmyra, new york to kirtland, ohio. Fawn mckay brodie september 15, 1915 january 10, 1981 was an american biographer and one of the first female professors of history at ucla, who is best known for thomas jefferson. But no man knows my history fundamentally questions the credibility of joseph smith. No man knows my history the life of joseph smith the mormon.